Startup founders often celebrate high valuations as victories. A $50 million valuation feels better than a $25 million one. But what many founders don’t realize until it’s too late is that high valuations come with constraints and expectations that can fundamentally reshape a company’s trajectory.

Operational Pressure and Forced Growth

A high valuation creates expectations for matching performance. A company valued at 20x revenue must deliver exceptional growth to justify its price tag. This pressure often leads companies to:

• Premature scaling before finding product-market fit
• Expand into tangent markets regardless of strategic fit
• Prioritizing growth metrics over unit economics

In 2020, Quibi shut down after raising $1.75B in funding. The company spent aggressively on content and marketing to justify its valuation. They burned through cash without getting enough users and shut down just six months after launch.

The relentless pursuit of growth to justify an inflated valuation creates a dangerous feedback loop. Companies become trapped in a cycle of artificial expansion, often leading to desperate decisions that compromise their core business model.

Inevitable Down Rounds

Companies that fail to grow into their valuations face painful down rounds. Carta’s State of Private Markets report shows that over the past three years, raising capital at a decreased valuation has become more common. In Q4 2024, about 19% of all new investments on Carta were down rounds, reflecting the widespread challenge of maintaining high valuations in changing market conditions.

Beyond the obvious financial implications, down rounds create:

• Employee morale problems when stock options lose value
• Problems with market perception (e.g. negative press cycles and recruitment challenges)
• Leadership credibility challenges

Narrowed Options

High valuations also eliminate decision flexibility precisely when startups need it most. This constraint can be felt when market conditions change or the company’s business model requires an adjustment. For example, companies locked into premium valuations can no longer consider:

• Early acquisition offers that would be life-changing for founders but ‘disappointing’ for late-stage investors
• Business model pivots that require temporary growth slowdowns
• Focusing on sustainable economics over growth-at-all-costs

Ultimately, pursuing the highest possible valuation creates a self-imposed “unicorn or bust” dynamic that eliminates the middle ground where many venture-backed companies could otherwise deliver strong returns for investors.

Choose Your Path Wisely

Venture capital isn’t just about maximizing valuation—it’s about optimizing for optionality. While a higher number on your term sheet might feel validating today, the true cost extends far beyond the dilution. An unwarranted premium can create constraints that shape, and often limit, every decision a startup will face. 

Smart founders understand this tradeoff. They fundraise not to maximize paper wealth, but to preserve their ability to make the right decisions as their business evolves.

Would you like to learn more about deal structuring and startup valuation? our next training sessions are coming.